Skip to content
Mon to Fri, 10 to 6, by appointment OCOrange County Coin BuyersCoins · Gold · Silver (562) 379-5480

Home › What we buy › Old coins and error coins

Selling old coins and error coins in Orange County

Albums and folders, proof sets, silver dollars and the coins people set aside because they look strange. We grade the good ones, check suspected errors and tell you plainly which coins are common.

Coin album with a loupe

Collections in Orange County

Many Orange County collections came west with families from the Midwest and Northeast in the 1950s and 1960s, then sat for decades in tract homes in Garden Grove, Costa Mesa and Huntington Beach. Retirement communities in Laguna Woods and Seal Beach hold thousands more.

We also see a lot of suspected errors. Social media has convinced many people that every odd-looking coin is worth a fortune. Most are not, and we explain why, but real errors do turn up and we pay for them.

Dates worth a second look

Most old coins are common. These get extra attention.

  • 1909-S VDB, 1914-D and 1955 doubled die cents
  • 1916-D Mercury dime
  • 1937-D three-legged buffalo nickel
  • 1932-D and 1932-S Washington quarters
  • 1893-S and Carson City Morgan dollars
  • Any S mint coin from the 1920s and 1930s

Telling errors from damage

Doubled lettering, off-center designs, missing layers and coins on the wrong metal can be real mint errors. Squeezed, hammered, plated or chemically treated coins are not. Under magnification, the difference is usually clear in a minute or two, and we show you what we see.

Proof and mint sets

Sets from 1964 and earlier contain 90 percent silver coins. Mint sets from 1965 through 1970 hold 40 percent halves. Clad proof sets from 1968 into the 1990s mostly sell near face. The Mint's silver proof sets, sold since 1992, hold real silver. Keep sets in their original packaging.

Coins from Laguna Woods and Seal Beach

The big retirement communities in south and west county produce a steady flow of collections. Many were built over a lifetime back East or in the Midwest and arrived here in a moving box. We see Barber silver, Indian Head cents and complete folders more often from these homes than anywhere else.

Silver dollars in OC estates

Morgan and Peace dollars are among the most common coins in local estates, often from the San Francisco mint with an S on the back. Most sell modestly above silver, while scarce dates and high grades are priced one by one.

Storage near the coast

Salt air speeds up toning and spotting, especially on copper. Coins in garages near the beach show it first. Please do not clean them. Move them indoors and bring them as they are.

Coins we buy

  • Indian Head and wheat cents
  • Buffalo and war nickels
  • Silver dimes, quarters and halves through 1964
  • Morgan and Peace dollars
  • Proof and mint sets
  • Mint errors and varieties
  • Certified coins in holders

How old coins are priced

U.S. silver coins dated 1964 and earlier are always worth at least their silver. Copper and nickel coins begin at face. Date, mint, grade and any true error decide how much more a coin brings.

Collector coins are listed one by one with grade and price, and common coins are grouped by type.

Further reading: Error coins and misprints

Questions families ask

Is my error coin real?

Many are damage after striking. We look under magnification and explain what we see.

Do you buy proof sets?

Yes. Silver sets carry silver value, and a few years bring more.

Should I clean my coins?

No. Cleaning lowers the value.

Request a free appraisal

We call back the same day to set a private time.

Families also ask us about

Silver and sterlingFree appraisals